Mathematics

For each of the statements given below, think and identify if it is Always True, Only Sometimes True, or Never True. Share your reasoning.

(a) If a person says ‘0’, then they are the tallest in the group.
(b) If a person is the tallest, then their number is ‘0’.
(c) The first person’s number is ‘0’.
(d) If a person is not first or last in line (i.e., if they are standing somewhere in between), then they cannot say ‘0’.
(e) The person who calls out the largest number is the shortest.
(f) What is the largest number possible in a group of 8 people?

Number Play

3 Likes

Answer

Recall the rule: each person’s number is the count of taller people standing in front of them.

(a) If a person says ‘0’, then they are the tallest in the group. → Only Sometimes True

Reason — Saying ‘0’ only means no one in front is taller; a taller person could still be standing behind them. For example, the front person always says ‘0’ but need not be the tallest.

(b) If a person is the tallest, then their number is ‘0’. → Always True

Reason — The tallest person has no one taller anywhere in the line, so the number of taller people in front of them is 0.

(c) The first person’s number is ‘0’. → Always True

The first person has no one in front of them, so there are 0 taller people in front, and they must say ‘0’.

(d) If a person is in between, then they cannot say ‘0’. → Only Sometimes True

Reason — A person standing in the middle can say ‘0’ if no one taller than them is standing in front. For example, in the arrangement 3, 7, 5, 4, 6, 2, 1, the second person (height 7) is not first or last, yet says ‘0’ because there is no taller person in front. However, in many arrangements, a person in the middle may have a taller person in front and therefore not say ‘0’.

(e) The person who calls out the largest number is the shortest. → Only Sometimes True

Reason — A large number means that many taller people are standing in front of that person. This may happen when the shortest person stands near the back of the line. However, the shortest person could also stand near the front and say a smaller number. Therefore, the person calling out the largest number is not always the shortest person.

(f) What is the largest number possible in a group of 8 people?

A person can have at most all the people in front of them being taller. The maximum number of people in front of anyone in a line of 8 is 7 (for the last person).

∴ The largest number possible is 7, said by the shortest child when placed at the very back.

Hence, the largest possible number in a group of 8 people is 7.

Answered By

1 Like


Related Questions