Mathematics
Using such reasoning, find out which other numbers 1 – 9 cannot occur at the centre of a magic square.
Number Play
1 Like
Answer
In a 3 × 3 magic square using the numbers 1–9, the magic sum is 15. Every row, column and diagonal passing through the centre must add up to 15.
We have already seen that 1 and 9 cannot be placed at the centre.
Using the same reasoning:
If 2 is at the centre:
1 + 2 + (third number) = 15
third number = 12
But 12 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 2 cannot be at the centre.
If 3 is at the centre:
1 + 3 + (third number) = 15
third number = 11
But 11 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 3 cannot be at the centre.
If 4 is at the centre:
1 + 4 + (third number) = 15
third number = 10
But 10 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 4 cannot be at the centre.
If 6 is at the centre:
6 + 9 + (third number) = 15
third number = 0
But 0 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 6 cannot be at the centre.
If 7 is at the centre:
7 + 9 + (third number) = 15
third number = −1
But −1 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 7 cannot be at the centre.
If 8 is at the centre:
8 + 9 + (third number) = 15
third number = −2
But −2 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 8 cannot be at the centre.
Thus, the numbers 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, and 8 also cannot occur at the centre.
The only number left is 5.
Hence, apart from 1 and 9, the numbers 2, 3, 4, 6, 7 and 8 also cannot occur at the centre. Therefore, 5 is the only number that can be placed at the centre of a 3 × 3 magic square formed using the numbers 1–9.
Answered By
2 Likes
Related Questions
Fill the grids below based on the rule mentioned above (the numbers in the yellow circles are the sums of the corresponding rows and columns):
Grid 1:

Grid 2:

Try solving the problem below.

Can 1 occur in a corner position of a magic square? If yes, then there should exist three ways of adding 1 with two other numbers to give 15. We have 1 + 5 + 9 = 1 + 6 + 8 = 15. Is any other combination possible?

Similarly, can 9 be placed in a corner position?