Mathematics
Similarly, can 9 be placed in a corner position?
Number Play
1 Like
Answer
As with 1, a corner cell lies on three lines, so placing 9 in a corner would require three different pairs of numbers (from 1 – 8) that each add with 9 to give 15, that is, three pairs summing to 15 – 9 = 6.
Listing all pairs of distinct numbers from 1 – 8 that add up to 6:
6 = 1 + 5
6 = 2 + 4
(3 + 3 is not allowed, since a number cannot repeat.)
So there are only two such pairs, giving 9 + 1 + 5 and 9 + 2 + 4. As a corner needs three lines but only two pairs exist, 9 cannot be placed in a corner either.
This confirms Observation 3: the numbers 1 and 9 cannot occur in any corner, so they must occur in one of the middle positions.
Hence, only two pairs of numbers add with 9 to give 15, so 9 also cannot occur in a corner position.
Answered By
2 Likes
Related Questions
Using such reasoning, find out which other numbers 1 – 9 cannot occur at the centre of a magic square.
Can 1 occur in a corner position of a magic square? If yes, then there should exist three ways of adding 1 with two other numbers to give 15. We have 1 + 5 + 9 = 1 + 6 + 8 = 15. Is any other combination possible?

Can you find the other possible positions for 1 and 9?

Now, we have one full row or column of the magic square! Try completing it!
[Hint: First fill the row or columns containing 1 and 9]