Mathematics
Using such reasoning, find out which other numbers 1 – 9 cannot occur at the centre of a magic square.
Answer
In a 3 × 3 magic square using the numbers 1–9, the magic sum is 15. Every row, column and diagonal passing through the centre must add up to 15.
We have already seen that 1 and 9 cannot be placed at the centre.
Using the same reasoning:
If 2 is at the centre:
1 + 2 + (third number) = 15
third number = 12
But 12 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 2 cannot be at the centre.
If 3 is at the centre:
1 + 3 + (third number) = 15
third number = 11
But 11 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 3 cannot be at the centre.
If 4 is at the centre:
1 + 4 + (third number) = 15
third number = 10
But 10 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 4 cannot be at the centre.
If 6 is at the centre:
6 + 9 + (third number) = 15
third number = 0
But 0 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 6 cannot be at the centre.
If 7 is at the centre:
7 + 9 + (third number) = 15
third number = −1
But −1 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 7 cannot be at the centre.
If 8 is at the centre:
8 + 9 + (third number) = 15
third number = −2
But −2 is not among the numbers 1–9.
∴ 8 cannot be at the centre.
Thus, the numbers 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, and 8 also cannot occur at the centre.
The only number left is 5.
Hence, apart from 1 and 9, the numbers 2, 3, 4, 6, 7 and 8 also cannot occur at the centre. Therefore, 5 is the only number that can be placed at the centre of a 3 × 3 magic square formed using the numbers 1–9.
Related Questions
Fill the grids below based on the rule mentioned above (the numbers in the yellow circles are the sums of the corresponding rows and columns):
Grid 1:

Grid 2:

Try solving the problem below.

Can 1 occur in a corner position of a magic square? If yes, then there should exist three ways of adding 1 with two other numbers to give 15. We have 1 + 5 + 9 = 1 + 6 + 8 = 15. Is any other combination possible?

Similarly, can 9 be placed in a corner position?